Posted By: CplCarrot | Jun 22nd @ 1:50 PM
page 1 of 1
Comments: 2 | Views: 698
CplCarrot
CplCarrot
Dust Puppy
Hi
 
My Netgear DG834g R1 wireless ADSL router has started to throw machines off its wireless network. This seems to be mostly Windows 7 machines (which I have most of)  but also hits Vista machines.
In the absence of any diagnostics I am building a business case for my bosses (Wife and work) to buy a new one.
My eye has been drawn to the Belkin N+ Does anyone have any views on this or any other solution?
My requirements are:
Must have:
  • ADSL Router built in. (I have more than enough wires as it is)
  • Wireless - Range over speed. 97% of the traffic on my network is to the internet where I get 2Mbs max but I need to have access some 20m (60 ft) away
 
Nice to have
  • NAS connection - Seems you can plug a USB hard drive to the Belkin and it acts as a NAS device but a slow one.
  • Guest Access - Allowing temp users to access the internet but not the network
  • Firewall
 
What sort of solution do you all run in support of all those sexy desktops that are posted?
 
Many thanks

I've found Belkin to be pretty awful, as have many friends. Anecdotal, of course, but I don't think I've seen anyone recommend them either. The setup UI was pretty poor (but may have improved now; I've avoided the brand since) and I had problems like the entire thing locking up, requiring a hard reboot, when my then-laptop (HP/Compaq FWIW) used the Wifi and transfered a large amount of data quickly.

Not sure what to recommend, though... I'm using a Thompson/Alcatel router at the moment which my ISP gave me... it's *almost* good, except that it's full of bugs (reboots itself if you do too much UPnP or VPN stuff... sigh). I went looking for a replacement and decided it was less irritating putting up with my current router than it was finding the best new one. Smiley

There are so many to choose from but every one seems to be missing some feature (e.g. all the NetGear ones seem to have 100mbit hubs like it's still the 1870s or something).

It's also made more complex by some manufacturers (NetGear especially) releasing new and unrelated routers with the same name as older ones. Makes it difficult to know exactly what you are buying, given that many online stores sell old/discontinued stock.

It boggles my mind why so many routers are still so buggy these days. Surely this stuff should be down pat by now. It's not like they do anything _that_ complicated or difficult to test, or different between vendors/models.

 

page 1 of 1
Comments: 2 | Views: 698
Microsoft Communities