Posted By: contextfree | Oct 31st @ 12:54 PM
page 1 of 1
Comments: 5 | Views: 346

I thought the purpose of the ribbon was to aid discoverability in applications with lots of features, as well as results-oriented editing through the live previews etc.  Finding things in WordPad isn't exactly a problem and the only live gallery is the colors.  The ribbon is a lose here because it wastes space (since only a small part of the tab bar is used, and if the app is maximized only a small part of the individual tab ribbons is used), and -- at least if the menus are small and don't have submenus -- clicking a tab -> clicking something in its ribbon isn't as smooth as clicking a menu -> selecting something in the menu (in Office this is mitigated by the minitoolbar, which you don't have in WordPad).

 

If the idea is to make MSFT applications more consistent, I don't think it's a worthwhile tradeoff in this case.  Menu-based applications aren't going away, nor should they (for the above reasons), so it's not like the overall cognitive overhead for users will decrease.  They'll still have to deal with other apps that are menu-based.  

Perhaps it's just there for show?

Double-click the Home ribbon tab to show/hide the ribbon. I totally agree with you that the lack of a mini-toolbar really hurts Wordpad (and Paint). I find the mini-toolbar more useful than the ribbon.

ManipUni
ManipUni
Proving QQ for 5 years!

The Word Pad and Paint ribbons make absolutely no sense and make the applications much harder to use. Paint goes from one of the easiest to learn simple drawing applications to one of the worst designed ones.

 

The only benefit that I can imagine (and I am playing devil's advocate) is that they're more usable with touch interfaces.

exoteric
exoteric
I : Next<I>

Consistency. There is some resistance mainly due to inertia when moving to a new interface. It is true however that Paint and Wordpad are sufficiently poor as to not benefit greatly from the ribbon.

ManipUni
ManipUni
Proving QQ for 5 years!

Paint is actually very good.

 

Something Linux still lacks. Yes, it is better than Gimp because it fills an entirely different niche.

page 1 of 1
Comments: 5 | Views: 346
Microsoft Communities