Comment Feed for Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry (Charles on Channel 9)

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

calin_iaru — Tue, 02 Sep 2008 14:42:18 GMT

This is great! My computer kept crashing and sent some minidumps. Someone from OCA flipped a bit and as I speak the full memory file is sent. Congratulations!

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

Ytterbium — Fri, 15 Aug 2008 23:13:18 GMT

Great video, I love the windows one get Mark to answer that question Charles

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

Calin Iaru — Fri, 15 Aug 2008 23:06:50 GMT

I agree with most viewers. This is a nice interview. We'd appreciate more form kernel.

Re: Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

tourist — Wed, 13 Aug 2008 13:59:07 GMT

Duke:

How big is your company and how many people work on pulling crash reports from winqual.microsoft.com?

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

karnokd — Wed, 13 Aug 2008 12:05:18 GMT

I usually click on send report when the crash details contain an access violation.

I think the reason for a single threaded UI is to avoid deadlocks. Usually there are two directions competing in an UI scenario: user input events and gui redraw events. One might create a clever multi-threaded gui but there are too many pitfalls for general purpose usage.

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

LightRider — Wed, 13 Aug 2008 01:58:47 GMT

Great video, very much appreciated. I always like how things I experience on a day to day basis are explained in depth. Please make more of these!

Re: Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

Charles — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 21:42:53 GMT

"Too bad this informative interview will have a tiny audience."

What makes you think this will be the case?
C

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

BSalita — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 21:35:54 GMT

Vince is an excellent interviewee. He's very eloquent. Too bad this informative interview will have a tiny audience.

I agree with Vince that Vista behaves itself nicely. I rarely have a problem at the OS level. Kudos to Microsoft. However, I pretty much always have problems, often relatively benign, with 3rd party drivers and apps. If Vince says his home computers behave themselves he certainly isn't using them as HD HTPCs. Windows is a long way away from being a wife approving HD entertainment platform. I yearn for the day when Windows is as robust as a TIVO. I concede this issue is immensely complicated and no other vendor has done HD HTPC right. I suspect that vendor bundling and open source will lead more quickly to a solution.

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

dnjake — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 21:23:10 GMT

The reason for a single UI thread is very simple. The use of a single thread results in no problem in synchronizing any of the message processing involved in presenting the UI. It is far from obvious that there is any problem with this situation as long as an application does not try to do some significant synchronous background processing on the UI thread. It is also the case that .net provides functionality that makes the use of a background thread easy for background processing in either a WinForms or a WPF environment. In practice with WPF it is easy to use three threads that could be running on three processors for the UI. Those threads include the standard UI thread, the render thread, and a background worker thread. Charles can rant on all he wants about the wonders of multicore. But it may take him a while to find the client workload that actually has any real requirement for more than two or three cores.

As far as Vista stability goes, it has been very good since I started using it during the RC0. I have had two or three blue screens in total during that time.

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

Charles — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 20:32:40 GMT

As Vince says in the conversation, those Windows dialogs asking you to send error data really make a difference in the overall stability of Windows and provide a tremendous amount of technical value to developers in the Windows application ecosystem...

Send!
C

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

John — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 20:16:11 GMT

What are Vists in the wild? lol

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

stevo_ — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 20:01:32 GMT

I think its also because the power of the windows platform is that its open and lets developers empower it.. its a joint effort, but in that there needs to be a joint responsibility for error.. right now windows gets all the blame, the only thing microsoft can do is try and help them be better developers and make less errors.. via this kind of work and making the os more stable etc etc..

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

dentaku — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 19:53:23 GMT

That was one of the most informative interviews in a while. It's unfortunate that the average person doesn't get to ever hear about the good work that people like Vince do and how passionate they are about making stuff work.

I like that they can collect information for OEMs and identify different models of machines (great for identifying driver problems because these types of machines all have identical hardware) but unfortunately it probably won't make them decide to stop with the shovelware because crashing usually isn't the problem with this kind of software, it's simply the annoyance of them and how they make the OS look bad even though it's not a component of the OS that's the problem.
In other words, the people at MS are afraid to tell their partners to stop messing up their nice new OS because it will make them look like a big bully when in fact they're just telling the truth.

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

Tomasz — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 19:34:35 GMT

Great stuff, i'm glad that I found those resources on channel9. I'm listening to that kind of talks with real pleasure.

Re: Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

Charles — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 18:19:53 GMT

That's the number of folks on his specific team (the first line of defense and composed of the very best people).

This is a cross-company effort with a lot of automation in place (automated static analysis and bug creation in the right product team's bug database - even assigning bugs to the right developer...).

Keep in mind that many of the application crashes on Windows are not caused by Windows and we work with thrid party developers to ensure rapid fix updates.

It goes without saying how important Vince and team are to Microsoft and our customers. Thank you!!!
C

Re: Vince Orgovan: Windows Vista Telemetry

CKurt — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 18:14:03 GMT

LOve the video ! Really gives some great insides on what microsoft does with crashes.

But i think 12 people is a bit low for a part of microsoft that is really really important !